Lessons from a Study on Hay Variability: Insights for Organic Producers

Hay quality can vary considerably among bales from the same field. Proper sampling and forage testing help organic livestock producers understand that variability and make better feeding decisions.

Technical content updated June 2026 to include recommendations for collecting representative hay samples.

Start with a Representative Hay Sample

I wrote this longer article back in October of 2024, but since we are in the midst of cutting hay right now, I thought an update would be a good thing! Before discussing the surprising variability found among individual hay bales from a single field, it is important to remember that a forage analysis is only as good as the sample submitted to the laboratory. Many producers still collect a handful of hay from the outside of a bale and send it for analysis. Unfortunately, this approach often provides misleading results because leaves, stems, and different portions of the bale are not represented equally.

The preferred method is to use a hay probe attached to a cordless drill and collect core samples from a minimum of 20 representative bales within a hay lot. A hay lot should consist of hay from the same field, cutting, forage type, and harvest period. I carry a bucket with me and put each core in the bucket as I sample a bale. The core sampler is a 24″ model since almost everyone has round bales today. The individual cores are combined into a single composite sample (the bucket), mixed thoroughly, and submitted to a forage testing laboratory.

A farmer using a core sampling tool to test hay quality while standing next to a large hay bale.

The picture above is a clip I copied from a longer article in Hay and Forage Magazine, April 2025 edition. The article is just a good reminder of proper sampling, but the best part of the article is a list of all the places to order a hay probe. Just click on the picture or here Hay Probes to see the list!

How Much Can Hay Vary Within One Field?

When it comes to hay production, many farmers assume that bales harvested from the same field will contain similar nutrient levels. The differences across fields was evident in a recent article by Michael Reuter in Progressive Forage1. His article and data show us all, the significant differences even among bales from the same field. Understanding and managing these differences can make a big impact, especially for organic farmers who want to optimize livestock nutrition and maintain a consistent quality of forage.

Stacked hay bales in a grassy area with a white wooden fence in the background.

The following table from the article1 presents the nutrient composition and analysis of 20 individual bales randomly sampled from an 86-acre hay field, which was managed as a unit and harvested all at the same time:

A table displaying nutritional data for hay bales, including columns for bale number, crude protein percentage (CP), acid detergent fiber percentage (ADF), neutral detergent fiber percentage (NDF), calcium percentage (CA), phosphorus percentage (P), starch percentage, water soluble carbohydrates percentage (WSC), and energy value percentage (ESC).

What the Bale Data Showed

The analysis of the 20 hay bales showed surprising variability in key nutrients such as Crude Protein (%CP), fiber content (measured as %ADF and %NDF), and essential minerals like Calcium (%CA) and Phosphorus (%P). Summary statistics of the nutrient composition are presented below:

Table displaying statistical data with columns for percentage values of CP, ADF, NDF, Starch, WSC, ESC, CA, and P, including average, standard deviation, minimum, maximum, and difference.

Crude protein, for example, varied from 9.7% to 15.9%. This 6.2 percentage point difference could significantly influence the nutritional value of hay fed to livestock.

Fiber levels also differed substantially. The ranges in Acid Detergent Fiber (%ADF) and Neutral Detergent Fiber (%NDF) directly affect how digestible the hay is and how much livestock will eat. Calcium and phosphorus levels, which are critical for bone health and metabolic functions, also showed noteworthy differences between bales.

Why Does Hay Quality Vary?

Even within a field managed and harvested as one unit, soil fertility, plant maturity, species composition, moisture, weeds, topography and microclimate can vary enough to influence forage quality. In organic fields, uneven manure or compost distribution can add another potential source of spatial variability:

  1. Soil Fertility Differences: Organic amendments like compost or manure may not be evenly spread across the field. Variability in soil nutrients can cause different areas of the field to produce hay with varying nutrient levels.
  2. Crop Rotation and Plant Diversity: Rotating different crops or allowing natural diversity in the field is beneficial for soil health, but it can also lead to differences in how well each crop absorbs nutrients.
  3. Pest, Weed, and Microclimate Effects: Organic fields often have more variability in pest pressure, weed growth, and microclimates. These differences can lead to uneven growth, which in turn affects nutrient content.

Managing Hay Variability

To minimize these differences and provide more consistent forage quality, farmers can take several practical steps:

  • Soil Testing: Regularly test soil across different sections of the field. This helps identify nutrient deficiencies or hotspots, allowing targeted amendment application.
  • Even Amendment Application: When applying compost, manure, or other organic fertilizers, try to ensure even distribution across the field. Variability in amendment application is a key factor in nutrient inconsistency.
  • Use Cover Crops: Cover cropping can help improve soil structure and increase nutrient cycling, which leads to more uniform plant growth.
  • Monitor Harvest Stages: Harvesting at a consistent plant maturity stage across the field can help reduce variability. Plants harvested at different growth stages can differ significantly in nutrient content.
  • Matching Regular Soil and Forage Testing: Applying soil nutrients based on soil tests and then testing multiple hay bales gives a clearer picture of the overall nutrient profile from start to finish. Testing hay allows adjustments in livestock feeding to meet nutritional needs effectively and maybe even save money!

Why This Matters for Organic Livestock

In organic livestock systems, purchased feed supplements must meet USDA organic requirements, and compliant organic feed ingredients can be expensive. Maximizing the nutritional value and consistency of farm-produced forage can therefore reduce purchased-feed needs and improve ration management. Variable hay quality can significantly impact livestock health, as inconsistencies in nutrition may lead to reduced growth rates, lower milk production, or other health issues. Moreover, optimizing the quality of on-farm forage can reduce the need for expensive purchased supplements and any organic supplements are not cheap.

Maintaining consistent forage quality also supports animal welfare, which is a core value of organic and sustainable farming. Healthy, well-fed animals are more resistant to disease, aligning with the organic principle of promoting natural immunity and reducing intervention.

The Take-Home Message

Variability is a natural part of farming, but with informed management, we can turn that variability into an opportunity for learning and improvement—ultimately providing better feed for our livestock and keeping our farms resilient.

Sources and Further Reading

1.Data Source: October 1, 2024 issue of Progressive Forage written by Michael Reuter, Analytical Services Technical Manager at Dairy One Cooperative Inc. and Equi-Analytical Labs.

Text graphic featuring the United States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Marketing Service National Organic Program and Transition to Organic Partnership Program, with a USDA Organic logo.

Organic fertilizer: what is it, what are the rules, and where do you buy it?

Organic fertilizer rules can be confusing. This guide explains what USDA organic standards allow for manure, compost, mined minerals and processed fertilizers, and lists Texas sources for bulk organic fertility products.

I get lots of general questions about what to use for fertilizer in organic agriculture. It is generally accepted that compost is good for organic, but does it have to be certified organic compost? What about manure? Can you buy some of these processed fertilizer products? What are the rules for fertilizers?

Click on any link below to scroll down!

The first place to start is with the National Organic Program rules and regulations.

(a) The producer must select and implement tillage and cultivation practices that maintain or improve the physical, chemical, and biological condition of soil and minimize soil erosion.
(b) The producer must manage crop nutrients and soil fertility through rotations, cover crops, and the application of plant and animal materials.
(c) The producer must manage plant and animal materials to maintain or improve soil organic matter content in a manner that does not contribute to contamination of crops, soil, or water by plant nutrients, pathogenic organisms, heavy metals, or residues of prohibited substances. Animal and plant materials include:


First let’s talk about raw animal manure, which must be composted unless it is:
(a) Applied to land used for a crop not intended for human consumption or,
(b) Incorporated into the soil not less than 120 days prior to the harvest of a product whose edible portion has direct contact with the soil surface or soil particles or
(c) Incorporated into the soil not less than 90 days prior to the harvest of a product whose edible portion does not have direct contact with the soil surface or soil particles.

A dirt path lined with dark mulch, surrounded by green grass and corn fields under a cloudy sky.

Second on the list is composted plant and animal materials produced through a process. This process involves the mixing of manures generally with some carbon sources like leaves, bark, hay, hulls, etc. to create a product that is:
(a) Establish an initial Carbon: Nitrogen ratio of between 25:1 and 40:1 and
(b) Maintains a temperature of between 131 °F and 170 °F for 3 days using an in-vessel or static aerated pile system or
(c) Maintains a temperature of between 131 °F and 170 °F for 15 days using a windrow composting system, during which period, the materials must be turned a minimum of five times.

A pile of compost or mulch material with visible organic matter, including wood chips and leaves, alongside a measurement stick.

Last in this list of NOP materials are Uncomposted plant materials. This is typically what you might call mulches like bark chips, leaves, grass, etc. These are used a lot in perennial crop systems to control weeds and add fertility over time.

Plant and animal materials used for fertility do not generally have to come from certified organic sources, but the material itself and its use must comply with USDA organic standards and must not introduce prohibited substances. Neither the animals or the plants that you use to make compost or just get raw manure or mulch has to be from an organic farm.

Let’s go back to the rules: A producer may manage crop nutrients and soil fertility to maintain or improve soil organic matter content in a manner that does not contribute to contamination of crops, soil, or water by plant nutrients, pathogenic organisms, heavy metals, or residues of prohibited substances by applying, if you follow these restrictions below.

(a) A crop nutrient or soil amendment included on the National List of synthetic substances allowed for use in organic crop production (click here for that list).
(b) A mined substance of low solubility.
(c) A mined substance of high solubility: Provided the substance is used in compliance with the conditions established on the National List of nonsynthetic materials prohibited for crop production.
(d) Ash obtained from the burning of a plant or animal material, except as prohibited in the list below.
(e) A plant or animal material that has been chemically altered by a manufacturing process: Provided, that the material is included on the National List of synthetic substances allowed for use in organic crop production.

The producer (that is you or any company that makes an organic fertilizer) must not use:
(a) Any fertilizer or composted plant and animal material that contains a synthetic substance not included on the National List of synthetic substances allowed for use in organic crop production.
(b) Sewage sludge (biosolids from a city sewage plant or from a septic tank or a mix of either source with plant material to make a compost).
(c) Burning as a means of disposal for crop residues produced on the operation: Except, That, burning may be used to suppress the spread of disease or to stimulate seed germination. We sometimes do a heat process to “sterilize” a plant material before using. Doubt you will ever need this part!

Protein hydrolysates are increasingly recognized for their role in organic fertilization strategies, offering a sustainable approach to enhance plant growth and soil health. Derived from proteins through hydrolysis, which breaks down proteins into smaller chains of amino acids or even individual amino acids, these products provide a readily available source of nitrogen and other nutrients to plants. This process can involve enzymatic, chemical, or thermal hydrolysis methods, each with its specific advantages and applications.

Nutrient Availability: Protein hydrolysates are particularly valued in organic agriculture for their rapid assimilation by plants. Protein hydrolysates can supply readily available amino acids and nitrogen, but plant response varies with product, rate, application method, soil conditions and crop.

Soil Health: Beyond providing nutrients, protein hydrolysates contribute to soil health. They support the growth and activity of beneficial microorganisms, which play a crucial role in soil nutrient cycling, organic matter decomposition, and the suppression of soil-borne diseases. This can lead to improved soil structure, water retention, and fertility over time.

Real Life Example: Consider a scenario where an organic farmer is growing lettuce, a crop that demands a consistent supply of nitrogen for leaf development. By applying a protein hydrolysate-based fertilizer, the farmer can provide a quick-acting source of nitrogen that is readily available for uptake by the lettuce plants. This not only supports the rapid growth of the lettuce but also contributes to the overall soil health by feeding the microbial life within the soil.

Problems? Yes, there are problems with some of these products. Nutrient availability is an issue. We have done experiments, and the product(s) may be slow to work in the plant or the actual nutrients may be lower than stated. This can be caused by a number of factors such as binding to soil or volatilization, but it does mean you need to know your source and product.

Sources: There are just too many to list! This new source for organic fertilizer is great to see but there are a lot of companies getting into this market. Just know that they are not cheap, companies can be far away meaning shipping is a big cost, and you need to know the product well. Verify that the specific product is allowed for your intended organic use and approved by your certifier before application. OMRI listing can be helpful, but it is not the only basis for acceptability. Sometimes these blends are with synthetic sources…….

South Plains Compost

  • PO BOX 190, Slaton, Texas 79364
  • Toll-free: 888-282-2000
  • Office: 806-745-1833
  • FAX: 806-745-1170 
  • Physical Address: 5407 East Highway 84Slaton, Texas 79364

Sigma AgriScience

  •  Office: 281-941-6944
  •  info@sigma-agri.com
  • Corporate Office
    580 Maxim Dr., Boling, TX 77420
  • Boling Plant
  • 2565 FM 1096, Boling, TX 77420
  •  Winnsboro Plant
  • 400 All Star Rd, Winnsboro, TX 75494

CS Nutrients

Morgan Bulk

  • 3075 FM 1116, Gonzales, Tx. 78629
  • Phone: 830-437-2855
  • Kerry Mobile: 830-857-3919
  • Bobby Morgan Mobile: 830-857-4761
  • Fax: 830-437-2856

7H Nutrients (Pelleted Product)

  • 8063 S US HWY 183, Gonzales, TX
  • Briant Hand
  • Mobile: 830-857-4340
  • 7hhand@gmail.com

Green Cow Compost

Microbes Biosciences (Rhizogen Granular)

Viatrac Fertilizer

Nature Safe Fertilizers

  • 5601 N Macarthur Blvd, Irving, TX, 75038
  • Main Phone: (469) 957-2725
  • Main Fax: (469) 957-2655
  • Natalie Starich (sales)
  • Mobile: (559) 410-3097
  • natalie.starich@naturesafe.com

Organics by Gosh

Earthwise Organics

Ferticell

  • Corporate: (480) 361-1300
  • Sales: (480) 398-8511
  • Fax: (480) 500-5967
  • info@ferticellusa.com
  • 5865 S. Kyrene Rd., Suite 1, Tempe, AZ 85283

True Organic Products

  • 1909 Fairhaven Gateway
  • Georgetown, TX 78626
  • Mobile (737) 403-0064
  • Corporate (831) 375-4796
  • Barret Milam-Regional Sales Representative-Texas
  • bmilam@true.ag
  • true.ag

How Organic Farming Practices Revive Soil Health and Microbial Diversity: Evidence from DNA Studies

Picture – RhizeBio.com (Decoding Nutrient Availability with DNA Soil Testing for Agriculture)

In recent years, scientific advances in DNA sequencing have allowed us to delve deeper into the hidden world of soil microbiomes—complex ecosystems of bacteria, fungi, and other microorganisms that play a crucial role in soil health. For certified organic farms, where soil vitality is central to crop productivity, DNA testing has become a powerful tool to track the rejuvenation of soil microbial life. Here are several case studies and research examples showing how organic practices can bring “dead” or degraded soils back to life, backed by peer-reviewed studies and long-term trials.

1. Rodale Institute’s Farming Systems Trial (FST)

The Rodale Institute’s Farming Systems Trial (FST) in Pennsylvania, one of the longest-running studies of its kind, has provided compelling evidence on how organic practices restore microbial life in soils. Comparing conventional and organic farming systems, the trial found that organic soils had higher microbial diversity and biomass, which supported better nutrient cycling, drought resilience, and overall soil health. This microbial community improvement was observed within just a few years of organic management.

  • Supporting Study: Rodale Institute. (2021). Rodale Institute Farming Systems Trial: 40-Year Report. Retrieved from: https://rodaleinstitute.org/science/farming-systems-trial/
  • Seufert, V., Ramankutty, N., & Foley, J. A. (2012). Comparing the yields of organic and conventional agriculture. Nature, 485(7397), 229-232. doi:10.1038/nature11069

2. University of California, Davis – Russell Ranch Sustainable Agriculture Facility

At the Russell Ranch Sustainable Agriculture Facility, part of UC Davis, researchers compared organic and conventional farming systems to understand their impact on soil health. DNA sequencing revealed that organic plots contained a significantly higher abundance of beneficial microbes, such as Actinobacteria and Proteobacteria, which are essential for decomposing organic matter and supplying nutrients to plants. Improvements in microbial diversity were observed within three years, showing how quickly organic management can enhance soil life.

  • Supporting Study: Bowles, T. M., Acosta-Martínez, V., Calderón, F., & Jackson, L. E. (2014). Soil enzyme activities, microbial communities, and carbon and nitrogen availability in organic agroecosystems across an intensively managed agricultural landscape. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 68, 252-262. doi:10.1016/j.soilbio.2013.10.004
  • University of California, Davis. Russell Ranch Sustainable Agriculture Facility. Retrieved from: https://russellranch.ucdavis.edu

3. USDA-ARS Study on Organic Transition in Salinas Valley, California

In California’s Salinas Valley, a USDA-ARS study focused on soil health during the transition from conventional to organic practices. DNA analysis was used to track microbial changes over time, showing that organic practices led to increased populations of beneficial organisms like Pseudomonas (known for disease suppression) and mycorrhizal fungi (which assist in nutrient uptake). Even heavily degraded fields showed signs of microbial recovery within three to five years under organic management.

The graph below illustrates how microbial diversity increased over several years under organic management, similar to what was observed in the USDA-ARS study in the Salinas Valley.

  • Supporting Study: Schmidt, J. E., Gaudin, A. C. M., & Scow, K. M. (2018). Cover cropping and no-till increase diversity and symbiotrophratios of soil fungal communities. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 129, 99-109. doi:10.1016/j.soilbio.2018.10.010
  • USDA Agricultural Research Service (ARS). Organic Agriculture Research and Extension Initiative (OREI). Retrieved from: https://www.ars.usda.gov

4. The DOK Trial in Switzerland (FiBL – Research Institute of Organic Agriculture)

The DOK trial in Switzerland, a long-term study by the Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL), compares biodynamic, organic, and conventional systems. DNA sequencing and microbial analysis have shown that the organic and biodynamic plots consistently feature higher microbial diversity and functionality. Within the first few years, these systems already showed greater resilience and microbial activity compared to conventional plots, highlighting the role of organic practices in fostering a healthy, living soil ecosystem.

  • Supporting Study: Mäder, P., Fließbach, A., Dubois, D., Gunst, L., Fried, P., & Niggli, U. (2002). Soil fertility and biodiversity in organic farming. Science, 296(5573), 1694-1697. doi:10.1126/science.1071148
  • FiBL – Research Institute of Organic Agriculture. DOK Trial: Long-Term Farming Systems Comparison in Switzerland. Retrieved from: https://www.fibl.org

5. Organic Almond and Grape Vineyards in California

In California, several almond and grape vineyards that transitioned to organic practices have used DNA analysis to monitor soil microbial changes. Within a few years, they reported a rise in beneficial mycorrhizal fungi and reduced pathogen levels, signaling a healthier, more resilient soil system. DNA sequencing tracked these positive shifts, confirming that organic management can replace harmful microbes with beneficial ones in soil over time.

  • Supporting Study: Steenwerth, K. L., & Belina, K. M. (2008). Cover crops enhance soil organic matter, carbon dynamics and microbiological function in a vineyard agroecosystem. Applied Soil Ecology, 40(2), 359-369. doi:10.1016/j.apsoil.2008.06.006
  • Hannula, S. E., & van Veen, J. A. (2016). The role of AM fungi in organic agriculture. Applied Soil Ecology, 96, 64-72. doi:10.1016/j.apsoil.2015.05.011

The Role of DNA Analysis in Understanding Soil Revival

DNA analysis has been a game-changer in soil science, allowing researchers to observe the specific microbial changes that occur when fields transition from conventional to organic management. By tracking shifts in microbial diversity and function, DNA testing provides clear, measurable evidence of how organic practices promote a healthy, balanced soil microbiome.

These studies illustrate that soil health restoration is achievable within a relatively short time under organic practices. While soils subjected to long-term conventional management may initially appear “dead” or lacking in microbial diversity, the examples above demonstrate that organic farming can foster microbial resilience and diversity, creating a foundation for sustainable, productive agriculture.

Organic farming practices have been shown to significantly improve soil health and microbial diversity compared to conventional farming methods. This article on recent DNA studies provides compelling evidence for the benefits of organic practices on soil ecosystems (eOrganic, 2023).

Increased Microbial Diversity and Abundance

Organic farming leads to greater microbial diversity and abundance in soils. Research in the Netherlands found that organically managed soils had higher numbers and more diverse populations of beneficial soil organisms compared to conventionally managed soils (Hartmann et al., 2015). Similar results were observed in banana plantation soils in Taiwan, with organic soils showing greater microbial diversity (Lehman et al., 2015). This increased microbial diversity is crucial for soil health, as it improves nutrient cycling, water retention, and disease suppression.

Enhanced Bacterial Communities

DNA studies reveal specific changes in soil bacterial communities under organic management. Organic systems show higher abundance of beneficial bacterial phyla like Acidobacteria, Firmicutes, Nitrospirae, and Rokubacteria (Hartmann et al., 2015). These bacterial groups correlate with improved soil biochemical properties and increased crop yields in organic systems (Lehman et al., 2015).

Improved Fungal Associations

Organic practices foster beneficial fungal relationships in the soil. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) colonization is higher in organic soils (Hannula & van Veen, 2016). AMF extend plant root systems, improving water and nutrient uptake, especially in challenging conditions like drought or high soil salinity.

Soil Organic Matter and Carbon Sequestration

Organic farming significantly increases soil organic matter content. The National Soil Project found organic soils averaged 8.33% organic matter content versus 7.37% in conventional soils (National Soil Project). Organic soils showed higher levels of sequestered carbon (4.1% vs 2.85%) and a greater percentage of organic matter in stable forms (57.3% vs 45%). This increased organic matter improves soil structure, water retention, and carbon sequestration potential.

Nitrogen Fixation and Nutrient Cycling

Organic practices enhance natural nutrient cycling processes. Research suggests organic soybean plants may develop more extensive fine root systems and nitrogen-fixing nodules compared to conventional crops (Lehman et al., 2015). The diverse microbial communities in organic soils contribute to more efficient nutrient cycling and availability for plants (Hartmann et al., 2015).

Soil Enzyme Activity

Organic management boosts soil enzymatic activity. Higher levels of alkaline phosphatase and β-glucosidase activity are observed in organic systems (Bowles et al., 2014). These enzymes play crucial roles in organic matter decomposition and nutrient release.

In conclusion, DNA studies provide strong evidence that organic farming practices revitalize soil health by fostering diverse and abundant microbial communities, improving soil structure, enhancing nutrient cycling, and increasing carbon sequestration. These benefits create a more resilient and sustainable agricultural ecosystem.

Sources for Further Reading:

Hartmann, M., Frey, B., Mayer, J., Mäder, P., & Widmer, F. (2015). Distinct soil microbial diversity under long-term organic and conventional farming. The ISME Journal, 9(5), 1177-1194. doi:10.1038/ismej.2014.210

Lehman, R. M., Cambardella, C. A., Stott, D. E., Acosta-Martínez, V., Manter, D. K., Buyer, J. S., … & Halvorson, J. J. (2015). Understanding and enhancing soil biological health: The solution for reversing soil degradation. Sustainability, 7(1), 988-1027. doi:10.3390/su7010988

These resources provide additional insights into how soil biology supports agriculture and the role of organic practices in enhancing microbial diversity.

Soil Testing: Understanding Your Results and Measuring Soil Health

Revision Note – November 2026: This publication has been substantially revised and expanded to provide updated guidance on soil sampling, interpreting routine soil fertility tests, and evaluating soil health. The revision clarifies the differences between soil fertility and soil health, expands information on the Haney Soil Health Test and aggregate stability, and emphasizes the importance of consistent sampling, laboratory methods, and long-term soil testing records. Additional information on soil biological activity, carbon measurements, and soil testing laboratories has also been updated to help producers make more informed soil management decisions.

Table of Contents

Why Test Soil?

I have taken thousands of soil samples over the years, and one thing I have learned is that a single soil test rarely tells the whole story.

A soil test is a snapshot of what was happening in that soil when the sample was collected. It can tell us a great deal about soil fertility, pH, salinity and other properties, but its value increases tremendously when we sample the same field consistently over time. Then we can begin to see trends. Is phosphorus accumulating? Is soil pH declining? Is salinity becoming a problem? Is soil organic carbon increasing? Are our management practices actually changing the soil?

That is why I encourage producers to think of soil testing as a long-term record rather than simply a fertilizer recommendation.

We also need to distinguish between a routine soil fertility test and the growing number of soil-health tests available today. They answer different questions. A conventional soil test remains the foundation for making nutrient and amendment decisions. Soil-health measurements can add information about soil structure, carbon cycling and biological activity, but they do not replace the basic soil test.

In this publication I will look at how to collect a good soil sample, what common soil tests actually measure, several soil-health tests now available, and some laboratories that producers may want to consider.

Taking a Representative Soil Sample

A soil test is only as good as the sample that goes to the laboratory. The laboratory may analyze the sample very precisely, but it cannot correct for a poor or unrepresentative sample collected in the field.

The first step is to divide the field into areas that are reasonably uniform. Differences in soil type, slope, drainage, cropping history, irrigation, manure application, or management may justify separate samples. Avoid mixing obviously different areas into one composite sample.

Above is a standard soil probe that will last you for years – well worth the cost.

Within each sampling area, collect multiple soil cores and combine them into one composite sample. The goal is to represent the field or management zone rather than one particular spot. Avoid unusual areas such as field entrances, old fence rows, livestock concentration areas, fertilizer spills, wet spots, or locations close to roads unless those areas are being sampled separately for a specific reason.

Sampling Depth Matters

Use the sampling depth recommended by the laboratory and by the soil-test calibration used for fertilizer recommendations. For many annual crops, routine surface soil samples are commonly collected from approximately the upper 6 inches of soil, although recommended depths vary by crop, region, and laboratory.

Consistency is especially important when comparing results over time. Changing from a 6-inch sample one year to an 8-inch sample the next can change nutrient concentrations simply because a different volume of soil was sampled.

Some nutrients require deeper sampling. Nitrate-nitrogen, for example, can move below the surface soil, so profile sampling may be needed when residual soil nitrate is important for fertilizer recommendations.

Sample Consistently Over Time

If the goal is to monitor changes in the soil, try to sample at approximately the same time of year, at the same depth, and under similar field conditions each time.

This becomes even more important when measuring soil health indicators such as respiration or other biological properties because soil moisture and temperature can strongly influence the results.

Where practical, record sampling locations with GPS or consistently sample the same management zones. Good records make it much easier to determine whether a change in a soil-test result reflects management or simply a change in where the sample was collected.

Use Clean Sampling Equipment

A soil probe or auger usually provides the most consistent sample, but a clean shovel can also be used when necessary. Use clean equipment and a clean plastic bucket for mixing composite samples.

Avoid introducing oils, fertilizers, manure, dust, or other materials that might contaminate the sample. This is particularly important when samples will be analyzed for carbon, micronutrients, biological activity, or contaminants.

Handling the Sample

After the cores are mixed thoroughly, place the amount requested by the laboratory into the appropriate sample container and label it clearly.

Follow the receiving laboratory’s instructions for drying, refrigeration, shipping, and sample preparation. Routine fertility samples and biological soil-health samples may require different handling procedures, so one method should not automatically be used for every type of analysis.

Good soil sampling is not complicated, but consistency matters. If I want to know whether a field is changing over time, I need to make sure I am comparing similar samples collected in similar ways.

What Does a Routine Soil Test Tell Me?

A routine agricultural soil test is designed primarily to help us evaluate soil fertility and identify chemical conditions that may limit crop growth. It does not measure every aspect of soil health, but it remains one of the most useful and economical management tools available to farmers.

Depending on the laboratory and the analyses requested, a routine soil test may include soil pH, salinity or electrical conductivity (EC), nitrate-nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, magnesium, sulfur, and selected micronutrients. Some laboratories also offer soil organic matter, texture, cation exchange capacity (CEC), or lime requirement as part of the basic package or as optional analyses.

Soil pH

Soil pH tells us how acidic or alkaline the soil is. This matters because pH strongly influences nutrient availability, microbial activity, and the effectiveness of some soil amendments.

An unexpected pH result deserves attention because correcting soil pH across an entire field can be expensive. If a result does not fit the field history or previous soil tests, I would rather verify it with another sample before making a major lime or amendment decision.

Salinity and Electrical Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is an indirect measure of soluble salts in the soil. Elevated salinity can reduce water uptake, interfere with nutrient availability, and injure sensitive crops.

In irrigated areas, greenhouses, high tunnels, dairies, and fields receiving repeated manure or compost applications, salinity deserves particular attention.

Nitrogen

Routine soil tests may measure nitrate-nitrogen, but nitrate is mobile and can change rapidly with rainfall, irrigation, crop uptake, and microbial activity. For this reason, nitrate testing is especially dependent on sampling depth and timing.

Where residual nitrate is important for fertilizer decisions, deeper profile sampling may be more informative than a surface sample alone.

Phosphorus and Potassium

Soil-test phosphorus and potassium are among the most common measurements used to guide fertilizer recommendations.

These tests do not measure all of the phosphorus or potassium present in the soil. Instead, laboratories use specific chemical extractants that have been calibrated against crop response to estimate the portion that is related to plant availability.

This is one reason it is important to know which laboratory and analytical method were used when comparing soil-test results over time.

Secondary Nutrients and Micronutrients

Calcium, magnesium, sulfur, zinc, iron, manganese, copper, boron, and other nutrients may be measured when needed.

Micronutrient results require careful interpretation because soil pH, organic matter, drainage, and crop species can strongly affect whether a measured nutrient is actually available to the plant.

Soil Organic Matter

Many laboratories report soil organic matter, and it can be useful for monitoring long-term changes in soil condition. Organic matter contributes to nutrient cycling, water-holding capacity, aggregation, and biological activity.

However, soil organic matter is not the same thing as soil organic carbon, and the two measurements should not be used interchangeably without understanding how the laboratory determined them.

The Value of Consistency

When I am tracking a field over time, I prefer to use the same laboratory, the same sampling depth, and the same analytical methods whenever possible.

Different laboratories may use different extractants, instruments, reporting units, or interpretation systems. If I switch laboratories, an apparent change in phosphorus, organic matter, or another measurement may reflect a change in method rather than a real change in the field.

The purpose of a routine soil test is not simply to generate numbers. It is to provide information that can guide nutrient management, identify developing problems, and help us make better decisions over time.

Of course, a normal soil test or what you might call a Regular Soil Test discussed above is a must. These are not usually expensive, +/- $15 or more with micronutrients. This test is of less value to me unless I have previous year’s results to see what is going on. I have taken literally thousands of soil samples and often I will see something show up that is off the charts. I am not known to panic when I see a problem because I am not going to react to that test unless I know it has steadily been a problem that is just getting worse. For instance, we can see pH swings in sand from one year to the next. Before I lime a soil, I may take a second sample just to verify I need lime. $15 soil test is cheaper than $60 per acre lime application.

Soil Fertility Is Not the Same as Soil Health

Soil fertility and soil health are closely related, but they are not the same thing.

Soil fertility focuses mainly on whether the soil can supply the nutrients a crop needs and whether chemical conditions such as pH or salinity may limit growth. A routine soil test is designed primarily to answer these questions.

Soil health is broader. It considers how well the soil functions as a living system. That includes physical properties such as aggregation, compaction, and water movement; chemical properties such as pH, salinity, and nutrient availability; and biological processes such as microbial activity, decomposition, and nutrient cycling.

A soil can be fertile without functioning particularly well as a soil ecosystem. For example, a field may test adequately for phosphorus and potassium but still have poor aggregation, surface crusting, restricted infiltration, or low biological activity. The opposite can also occur: a soil may have active biology and good structure but still have a nutrient deficiency or an unsuitable pH.

That is why I do not view soil health testing as a replacement for routine soil testing. Instead, the two approaches complement each other.

A routine soil test helps answer:

“Do I have the nutrients and chemical conditions needed to grow this crop?”

Soil health measurements help answer:

“How well is this soil functioning, and is that function improving or declining over time?”

As interest in soil health has increased, laboratories have developed many additional measurements, including soil respiration, soil organic carbon, aggregate stability, active or labile carbon, biologically available nitrogen, phospholipid fatty acid analysis (PLFA), and DNA-based microbial testing.

These tests can provide useful information, but they do not all measure the same thing. Understanding what each test actually measures is more important than simply ordering a large soil health package and receiving a single score.

The next sections look at several of these measurements and how they can fit alongside a routine soil fertility test.

Where Does the Haney Soil Health Test Fit?

The Haney Soil Health Test was developed to provide additional information about biologically active carbon and nitrogen pools and microbial activity in soil. It does not replace a conventional soil fertility test; instead, it helps answer some different questions about how carbon and nutrients are cycling through the soil.

One of the best-known measurements associated with the Haney approach is soil respiration. A dried soil sample is rewetted and the carbon dioxide released during a defined incubation period is measured. This CO₂ release reflects microbial activity as soil organisms begin using available carbon after rewetting.

The Haney approach also measures water-extractable organic carbon (WEOC) and water-extractable organic nitrogen (WEON). These represent relatively soluble portions of the soil organic carbon and nitrogen pools that can participate in biological cycling.

Understanding a Haney Soil Health Test Report

A Haney Soil Health Test report provides several measurements related to soil biological activity, carbon and nitrogen cycling, and nutrient availability. The exact information reported depends on the laboratory and the analytical package selected.

Three measurements are particularly important:

  • Soil respiration (CO₂-C burst): Estimates potential microbial activity following rewetting and incubation.
  • Water-extractable organic carbon (WEOC): Measures a soluble carbon pool that may provide energy for soil microorganisms.
  • Water-extractable organic nitrogen (WEON): Measures water-extractable organic nitrogen that may participate in microbial nitrogen cycling and subsequent mineralization.

These three measurements are also used to calculate the Haney Soil Health Score. The score summarizes selected biological indicators, but it should not be interpreted as a complete measurement of soil health. Soil structure, water infiltration, compaction, and other important soil properties are not directly included.1

Depending on the laboratory, a Haney report may also provide pH, electrical conductivity, nitrate and ammonium nitrogen, extractable phosphorus and potassium, other nutrients, and estimates of potentially mineralizable nitrogen. Some laboratories provide additional conventional analyses or fertilizer recommendations.

An important distinction is that the Haney test uses water extractions and the H3A extractant for certain nutrient measurements. These results are not necessarily equivalent to those obtained using conventional soil-test methods calibrated for fertilizer recommendations.

**For making fertilizer decisions, I prefer to use regionally calibrated soil fertility recommendations while treating Haney measurements as additional information about soil carbon and nitrogen cycling.**2

Example of a Haney Soil Health Test report showing biological activity, water-extractable carbon and nitrogen, and other soil measurements. Report components and interpretations may vary among laboratories.

I encourage producers to examine the individual measurements rather than concentrating only on the Soil Health Score. Consistent sampling, comparable laboratory methods, and results collected over several years are more useful for evaluating management changes than a single report.

It is important not to confuse these measurements with the conventional nutrient extractions used for fertilizer recommendations. A routine soil test and a Haney-type test are measuring different soil pools and answering different management questions.

The Haney measurements can be particularly useful when I want to monitor changes associated with practices such as cover crops, reduced tillage, manure or compost applications, crop rotations, or other practices intended to increase biological activity and carbon cycling.

However, a single Haney Soil Health Score should not be treated as a complete description of soil health. Soil texture, climate, cropping system, sampling conditions, and inherent soil properties all influence biological measurements. I place more value on the individual measurements and how they change over time than on comparing one overall score among very different soils.

The Haney approach has also become more closely connected with current USDA soil-health testing. NRCS now recognizes water-extractable organic carbon as an alternative method for measuring labile carbon and water-extractable organic nitrogen as an alternative method for measuring bioavailable nitrogen under its CEMA 216 Soil Health Testing framework.3

That does not mean the Haney test measures everything we need to know about soil health. It does mean that several of its measurements provide useful information about important biological processes when they are interpreted alongside routine soil fertility tests and other physical and biological indicators.

Aggregate Stability: Will the Soil Stay Together?

One of the most useful physical measurements of soil health is aggregate stability.

Soil particles naturally bind together into groups called aggregates. These aggregates create pore spaces that allow water and air to move through the soil and provide pathways for roots. Good aggregation is one reason a well-structured soil can absorb rainfall rather than sealing over and producing runoff.

Aggregate stability measures how well those soil aggregates resist breaking apart when they are exposed to water or other physical forces.4

This matters because unstable aggregates can break down during rainfall or irrigation. Fine particles may then clog surface pores, form a crust, reduce infiltration, and increase runoff and erosion. A soil may contain adequate nutrients and still perform poorly if its physical structure has deteriorated.

What Helps Build Stable Aggregates?

Aggregate stability develops through a combination of physical, chemical, and biological processes.

Plant roots help bind soil particles and create channels through the soil. Fungal hyphae can physically connect particles, while bacteria and other microorganisms produce compounds that help bind particles together. Organic matter also plays an important role in forming and stabilizing aggregates.

Management practices can therefore influence aggregate stability. Crop rotations, cover crops, living roots, organic amendments, and reduced soil disturbance may help improve aggregation over time. Intensive tillage, low residue return, erosion, and other disturbances can weaken soil structure.

Soil type also matters. A sandy soil naturally behaves very differently from a clay soil, so aggregate stability should not be interpreted without considering texture, mineralogy, climate, and management history.

How Is Aggregate Stability Measured?

There are several ways to measure how well soil aggregates resist breaking apart when exposed to water. Some methods are simple enough for farmers to use themselves, while others require specialized laboratory equipment. The methods differ in how water is applied and how aggregate breakdown is measured, so their results are not necessarily interchangeable.

Slaking Image Analysis — The SLAKES Smartphone App

One of the easiest methods for farmers to use is the free SLAKES smartphone application developed by the Soil Health Institute.

The procedure involves placing three dry soil aggregates into water and using a smartphone camera to photograph how they change over a 10-minute period. The application analyzes the images and calculates an aggregate stability index.

I particularly like this approach because farmers can use it themselves without expensive laboratory equipment. It provides a practical way to compare soil from different fields, management practices, or locations within a field, although soil type and sample preparation must be considered when interpreting the results.

The application also makes an excellent teaching tool. Farmers can actually watch soil aggregates break apart or remain intact when exposed to water.

Soil Health Institute: How to Use the SLAKES Smartphone App

Cornell Rainfall Simulation Method

The Cornell Soil Health Laboratory uses a rainfall simulation approach to evaluate wet aggregate stability. A known quantity of soil aggregates is placed on a sieve and exposed to water droplets from a rainfall simulator.

Aggregates that break apart pass through the sieve, while the material remaining is used to calculate the percentage of water-stable aggregates.

This approach is especially useful because it simulates the impact of raindrops on soil aggregates, one of the processes contributing to surface sealing, crusting, and erosion.

Wet Sieving Procedure

Wet sieving is a widely used laboratory approach for measuring aggregate stability. Soil aggregates are placed on sieves and exposed to water, often with controlled movement of the sieves.

The amount and size distribution of aggregates remaining after the procedure are used to evaluate stability.

Wet sieving can provide quantitative measurements for comparing treatments and tracking changes over time. However, the results depend on details such as sample preparation, sieve sizes, wetting procedures, and agitation, making consistent methods particularly important.

Mean Weight Diameter (MWD)

Mean weight diameter is not a separate testing procedure but a calculated measurement commonly obtained from aggregate size distribution following wet sieving.

It represents the weighted average diameter of the aggregate fractions remaining after testing. A larger MWD generally indicates that larger aggregates have remained intact, although interpretation depends on the soil and testing method.

MWD is frequently used in soil research to compare management practices and evaluate changes in soil structure.

Which Method Should Farmers Use?

For farmers interested in learning about aggregate stability without sending samples to a laboratory, I would begin with the SLAKES application. It is inexpensive, relatively easy to use, and provides a way to observe the physical behavior of soil aggregates.

For research trials or long-term monitoring programs requiring standardized quantitative measurements, laboratory methods may be more appropriate.

Regardless of the method, I would emphasize collecting comparable samples, following the same procedure each time, and interpreting results in the context of soil texture and management history.

Why I Like This Measurement

Aggregate stability tells us something that a conventional nutrient test cannot.

A routine soil test may tell me that phosphorus, potassium, and pH are all within acceptable ranges. Aggregate stability helps tell me whether the soil itself has the physical structure needed to accept water, resist erosion, and support roots.

For that reason, I think aggregate stability is one of the more practical soil-health measurements available. It connects a laboratory number with something farmers can often see in the field after a hard rain: does water enter the soil, or does the surface seal and the water run off?

Like most soil-health measurements, aggregate stability is most useful when it is followed over time and compared with similar soils under similar conditions.

Soil Organic Carbon: A Long-Term Measure of Soil Health

Soil organic carbon (SOC) is one of the most important measurements we can use to evaluate long-term changes in soil health. Carbon enters the soil primarily through plant roots, crop residues, cover crops, and organic amendments such as manure and compost. Some of that carbon is rapidly decomposed by soil organisms, while other portions can remain in the soil for years or even decades.5

Soil organic carbon is closely associated with many of the functions we want from a healthy soil.6 It contributes to aggregate formation and stability, supports microbial activity and nutrient cycling, and can improve water-holding capacity. Increasing soil carbon is often an important goal of regenerative and organic production systems.

Soil Organic Carbon Is Not the Same as Soil Organic Matter

Many farmers are familiar with soil organic matter (SOM) because it has been reported on soil tests for decades. However, soil organic matter and soil organic carbon are not the same measurement.

Soil organic matter includes carbon along with oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen, sulfur, and other elements found in decomposed plant and animal materials. Soil organic carbon measures only the carbon portion of that organic material.

Historically, soil organic matter has often been estimated by multiplying soil organic carbon by 1.724, based on the assumption that organic matter contains approximately 58% carbon.7 However, the carbon content of soil organic matter varies among soils, so this conversion is only an approximation.

When monitoring changes through time, it is important to know whether the laboratory reports measured organic carbon, measured organic matter, or a value calculated from another measurement.

How Is Soil Organic Carbon Measured?

Dry combustion is a widely accepted method for measuring soil carbon. However, the laboratory must distinguish organic carbon from inorganic carbon, particularly in calcareous soils containing calcium carbonate. Depending on the analytical procedure, this may involve removing or separately determining inorganic carbon.8

For this reason, I want to know whether my laboratory is reporting total carbon or specifically soil organic carbon, particularly when working with calcareous soils.

Why Soil Organic Carbon Changes Slowly

Unlike soil nitrate or microbial respiration, soil organic carbon generally changes slowly. Even when management practices improve soil carbon storage, detecting those changes through routine soil sampling can be difficult. Research by Wuest and Durfee (2024) demonstrated substantial variation in soil organic carbon measurements between sampling dates, emphasizing that small differences between individual soil tests may not represent meaningful changes in soil carbon.9 For this reason, I place greater confidence in carefully collected measurements over several years than in comparisons between just two sampling dates.

In many agricultural fields, measurable changes may require several years or longer. Small differences between annual soil tests may reflect normal sampling and laboratory variability rather than a real change in soil carbon.

For that reason, I generally view soil organic carbon as a long-term measurement rather than something that needs to be tested every year. Establishing a reliable baseline and repeating the measurement at consistent intervals, perhaps every three to five years, may be more useful for many producers.

Carbon Concentration Versus Carbon Storage

There is another important distinction. A laboratory usually reports soil organic carbon as a concentration, often expressed as a percentage of the dry soil.

That percentage is not the same as the total amount of carbon stored in a field.

To estimate carbon storage per acre, we also need to know the soil depth and bulk density, which describes the mass of dry soil within a given volume. This distinction becomes especially important when comparing tilled and no-till soils because changes in soil density can affect carbon storage calculations.10

What I Want Farmers to Remember

I would not judge the success of a soil management program by whether soil organic carbon increased a small amount in a single year. I would look for a consistent trend over time, supported by other measurements such as aggregate stability, infiltration, and biological activity.11

Soil organic carbon is an important indicator of soil condition, but it is not a complete soil-health measurement by itself. A field may have relatively low organic carbon because of its texture and climate yet still be functioning well for that particular soil.

The goal is to understand the soil we have, measure it consistently, and determine whether our management is improving its ability to support productive agriculture over time.

Soil Respiration: Measuring Biological Activity

Soil is a living system, and the organisms living in it are constantly using carbon as an energy source. As microorganisms decompose crop residues, roots, and soil organic matter, they release carbon dioxide (CO₂) through respiration. Plant roots and soil animals also contribute to total soil respiration.

Measuring soil respiration provides information about biological activity and the decomposition processes involved in nutrient cycling. Unlike soil organic carbon, which measures a relatively large pool of carbon stored in the soil, respiration measures carbon being released through biological processes.12

How Is Soil Respiration Measured?

Several methods are used to measure soil respiration. Some measure CO₂ released directly from soil in the field, while others use soil samples incubated under controlled laboratory conditions.13

One commonly used laboratory method is the 24-hour CO₂ burst test, which is associated with the Haney Soil Health Test. A soil sample is dried, rewetted, and incubated under controlled conditions. The CO₂ released during the following 24 hours is measured as an indicator of potential microbial activity.

Rewetting dry soil often produces a rapid increase in microbial respiration as microorganisms respond to the availability of water and organic substrates. Research has demonstrated that this CO₂ flush is related to biologically active soil organic matter and other indicators of soil microbial activity.14

Other laboratory methods use longer incubation periods, such as three or four days. Because incubation time, temperature, moisture, and measurement procedures can influence the results, values obtained using different methods should not be assumed to be directly comparable.15

Does Higher Respiration Mean Healthier Soil?

Not necessarily.

Higher respiration under standardized laboratory conditions often indicates greater potential microbial activity or more readily decomposable organic material. However, respiration also represents carbon being released from the soil as CO₂.

For example, tillage can temporarily stimulate microbial activity by exposing previously protected organic matter to decomposition. The resulting increase in respiration does not necessarily mean that soil health has improved.

Likewise, low respiration may reflect limited organic material, but it can also result from unfavorable conditions such as drought, excessive moisture, or low temperatures.

I would be cautious about assigning universal ratings of good or poor soil health based on a single respiration measurement. Soil texture, carbon content, management history, and analytical methods all affect the results.16

Why I Find Respiration Useful

Soil respiration provides information that a conventional fertility test cannot. It helps us understand how actively microorganisms are processing organic material and participating in carbon and nutrient cycling.

For organic and regenerative producers, respiration measurements may be useful for monitoring changes associated with cover crops, crop rotations, organic amendments, and reduced tillage.

However, I would not use respiration alone to judge whether a management practice is improving soil health. I would interpret it alongside soil organic carbon, aggregate stability, routine fertility measurements, and the history of the field.

Soil organic carbon tells us something about the carbon stored in the soil. Soil respiration tells us something about the biological activity using that carbon. Both measurements are useful, but neither tells the complete story.

As with other soil-health indicators, the greatest value comes from consistent sampling, comparable laboratory methods, and measurements collected over time.

Advanced Soil Biological Testing: PLFA and DNA Analysis

Soil microorganisms play essential roles in decomposing organic matter, cycling nutrients, forming soil aggregates, and interacting with plant roots. While soil respiration provides a general measurement of biological activity, other laboratory tests can provide information about the size and composition of soil microbial communities.

Two approaches used in soil research and commercial soil testing are phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) analysis and DNA-based microbial testing. These methods provide different types of information, and neither should be considered a complete measurement of soil health.

Phospholipid Fatty Acid (PLFA) Analysis

Phospholipid fatty acids are important components of microbial cell membranes. Different microbial groups contain characteristic fatty acids, and laboratory analysis of these compounds can provide estimates of microbial biomass and broad differences in community composition.

PLFA analysis generally involves extracting lipids from a soil sample, separating the fatty acids, and measuring them using specialized laboratory instruments.

Because phospholipids break down relatively quickly after microorganisms die, PLFA analysis is commonly used as an indicator of the living microbial community rather than the total microbial material present in soil.17

What Can PLFA Tell Us?

PLFA results may include estimates of total microbial biomass, bacterial and fungal biomass, and the relative abundance of broad microbial groups.18

These measurements can help researchers evaluate how soil microbial communities respond to crop rotations, cover crops, tillage, organic amendments, and other management practices.

For example, a long-term cropping experiment might use PLFA to determine whether microbial biomass or community composition changes following the introduction of cover crops or reduced tillage.

Some laboratories also report a fungal-to-bacterial ratio. While changes in this ratio may reflect differences in soil conditions or management, there is no universal ratio that defines a healthy agricultural soil.

PLFA does not ordinarily identify individual microbial species, and it does not directly measure whether microorganisms are actively performing particular functions such as nitrogen fixation or phosphorus mineralization.19

Limitations of PLFA Testing

Microbial communities respond rapidly to environmental conditions, including soil moisture, temperature, plant growth, and recent management activities.

For this reason, PLFA measurements can vary considerably between sampling dates. Sample handling and storage are also particularly important because microbial lipids can change or degrade after collection.

PLFA is useful for research and for monitoring changes in microbial communities under controlled sampling conditions. However, I would not recommend it as a routine replacement for conventional soil testing or the more established soil-health indicators.

For most producers, the additional cost and difficulty of interpreting the results should be considered before ordering this analysis.

DNA-Based Soil Microbial Testing

DNA-based soil testing uses genetic information extracted from soil to characterize microorganisms and, depending on the analytical method, identify particular organisms or genes associated with biological functions.

Unlike PLFA, which characterizes broad microbial groups through cell-membrane lipids, DNA sequencing can provide much greater detail about the organisms represented in a soil sample.

Some commercial services use this technology to assess microbial communities, detect genetic signatures associated with plant pathogens, or evaluate genes involved in nutrient cycling.

One example is Trace Genomics, whose technology and products were acquired by Miraterra in July 2025. The company has developed soil analysis services combining genomic information with conventional soil chemistry and agronomic interpretation.20

What Can DNA Testing Actually Tell Farmers?

DNA testing can be especially useful when there is a specific question, such as whether a soil contains genetic evidence of a particular plant pathogen or whether management practices are associated with changes in microbial community composition.

However, detecting an organism or a gene does not necessarily mean that the organism is alive, actively performing that function, or affecting crop growth under current field conditions.

For example, detecting genes associated with phosphorus solubilization indicates biological potential, but it does not establish how much phosphorus is actually being released and made available to a growing crop.

Similarly, detecting DNA from a plant pathogen does not necessarily mean that disease will develop. Disease depends on a susceptible host, a capable pathogen, and environmental conditions favorable for infection.

These technologies are advancing rapidly, but interpretation remains challenging. For most producers, DNA-based analyses are likely to be most useful when addressing a specific management or plant-health question rather than as a routine annual soil-health measurement.21

Which Biological Test Should I Use?

I encourage farmers to begin with the question they are trying to answer.

If I want to know whether biological carbon cycling is changing, soil respiration may be a useful starting point.

If I want to study changes in microbial biomass or broad community composition, PLFA may provide additional information.

If I am investigating particular microorganisms, soilborne pathogens, or microbial genes, DNA-based testing may be more appropriate.

The most expensive or technologically advanced test is not necessarily the most useful. The value of any soil test depends on whether its results help us understand the soil and make better management decisions.

Great publication you can read on understanding these Soil Health Tests. Just click the link below:

How to Understand and Interpret Soil Health Tests

The “take home” message is not soil testing only, but records of soil tests you can see over time!

Putting Soil Testing to Work

After years of collecting soil samples and working with producers, I have come to appreciate that the value of soil testing is not simply the number of measurements we can obtain. It is understanding what those measurements tell us and how we can use them to make better management decisions.

For most producers, I would begin with a good routine soil fertility test. If I want to understand changes in soil health, I might add measurements such as soil organic carbon, aggregate stability, or biological activity. More specialized tests, including PLFA and DNA analysis, may be useful when there is a specific question about the soil microbial community.

Regardless of the tests selected, consistent sampling and good records are essential. A single soil test provides useful information, but a series of comparable tests can help us recognize trends, evaluate management practices, and identify developing problems.

The goal is not to collect more soil-test numbers. The goal is to understand our soil well enough to manage it better.

Soil Testing Laboratories: Options for Producers

  • Ward Laboratories, Inc.
  • www.wardlab.com
  • 4007 Cherry Ave, Kearney, NE 68847
  • (800) 887-7645
  • TPS Lab
  • www.tpslab.com
  • Joe Pedroza, Business Development Manager
  • 4915 W. Monte Cristo Rd, Edinburg, TX 78541
  • Office: (956) 383-0739
  • Cell: (956) 867-7480
  • Midwest Laboratories
  • https://midwestlabs.com/
  • 13611 B Street, Omaha, Nebraska 68144
  • contactus@midwestlabs.com
  • Office: (402) 334-7770
  • Fax: (402) 334-9121

References

  1. Bellows, B., Morris, M., & Mitchell, C. (2020). Soil Health Indicators and Tests. ATTRA Sustainable Agriculture, Publication IP603. National Center for Appropriate Technology. ↩︎
  2. Stahl, L. A. B., Fernández, F. G., & Kaiser, D. E. (2018). Can soil health tests determine fertilizer needs? University of Minnesota Extension. ↩︎
  3. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2026). Soil Health Testing. Conservation Evaluation and Monitoring Activity (CEMA) 216, January 2026R. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  4. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2026). Soil Health Testing. Conservation Evaluation and Monitoring Activity (CEMA) 216, January 2026R. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  5. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2025). Soil Health Testing to Support Conservation Planning. Soil Health Technical Note No. 470-16. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  6. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2026). Soil Health Testing. Conservation Evaluation and Monitoring Activity (CEMA) 216, January 2026R. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  7. Pribyl, D. W. (2010). A critical review of the conventional SOC to SOM conversion factor. Geoderma, 156(3–4), 75–83. ↩︎
  8. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension — Soil, Water and Forage Testing Laboratory Methods. ↩︎
  9. Wuest, S. B., & Durfee, N. (2024). Temporal variability is a major source of uncertainty in soil carbon measurements. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 88(3), 830–845. ↩︎
  10. USDA NRCS — Soil Organic Carbon Stock Monitoring, CEMA 221 ↩︎
  11. Zuber, S. M., Veum, K. S., Myers, R. L., Kitchen, N. R., & Anderson, S. H. (2020). Role of inherent soil characteristics in assessing soil health across Missouri. Agricultural & Environmental Letters, 5(1), e20021. ↩︎
  12. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (n.d.). Soil Health Assessment. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  13. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2026). Soil Health Testing. Conservation Evaluation and Monitoring Activity (CEMA) 216, January 2026R. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  14. Franzluebbers, A. J., Haney, R. L., Honeycutt, C. W., Schomberg, H. H., & Hons, F. M. (2000). Flush of carbon dioxide following rewetting of dried soil relates to active organic pools. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 64(2), 613–623. ↩︎
  15. Franzluebbers, A. J., & Veum, K. S. (2020). Comparison of two alkali trap methods for measuring the flush of CO₂. Agronomy Journal, 112(2), 1279–1286. ↩︎
  16. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (n.d.). Soil Health Assessment. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  17. Frostegård, Å., Tunlid, A., & Bååth, E. (2011). Use and misuse of PLFA measurements in soils. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 43(8), 1621–1625. ↩︎
  18. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2026). Soil Health Testing. Conservation Evaluation and Monitoring Activity (CEMA) 216, January 2026R. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  19. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2019). Recommended Soil Health Indicators and Associated Laboratory Procedures. Soil Health Technical Note No. 450-03. U.S. Department of Agriculture. ↩︎
  20. Miraterra Technologies Corporation. (2025, July 7). Miraterra acquires Trace Genomics technology and products to unlock measurement and insights across soil, plants, and food. ↩︎
  21. Fierer, N., Wood, S. A., & Bueno de Mesquita, C. P. (2021). How microbes can, and cannot, be used to assess soil health. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 153, Article 108111. ↩︎

Other Resources:

Best Cover Crops for Weed Control and Fertility

Cover crops play a pivotal role in sustainable agriculture by enhancing soil health, managing pests and diseases, and improving overall crop yield resilience. Cover crops can be any non-harvested crop used primarily to protect soil from erosion during off-season periods, provide actively growing roots to extract and stabilize nutrients that might be otherwise vulnerable to leaching or volatile loss, and increase levels of SOM to promote soil physical properties and C sequestration. Cover crops have other values to farmers, as some crops can also be harvested for forage or seed or to diversify the cropping system
to suppress diseases, obtain other crop rotation benefits, improve off-season access to fields, or extract water during wet periods.

As a source of additional C delivered to soil during non-cash-crop growing periods (e.g., in fall and winter in many temperate regions), cover crops are particularly effective in supplying soil microorganisms with readily available carbon sources from both root exudates during growth and C-rich crop residues upon termination. Several studies have found greater soil organic carbon sequestration with implementation of cover crops (Poeplau and Don, 2015).
Often combined with no-tillage, management of cropland with cover cropping can enhance soil organic C sequestration due to addition of organic materials growing directly on land rather than imported from another location.

  1. Sorghum Sudangrass
  2. Sunn Hemp
  3. Cowpea
  4. Winter Cover Crops
  5. Cereal Rye
  6. Mustards
  7. Vetch
  8. Wheat (Triticum spp.)
  9. Oats (Avena sativa)
  10. Barley (Hordeum vulgare)
  11. Triticale (× Triticosecale)
  12. Daikon Radish or Tillage Radish
  13. Purple Top Turnip
  14. Other Resources (just click a title)

In the summer we plant sorghum sudangrass (top picture) for weed control because it has an allelopathic effect on weeds (click that link to read about it) and it shades any weeds coming on later. It is a vigorous and versatile cover crop that stands out for its exceptional contribution to soil health and weed suppression. Its rapid growth and dense canopy make it highly effective at outcompeting weeds, thus reducing the reliance on herbicides. This competitive growth habit is instrumental in shading out weeds, significantly lowering weed biomass and seed bank potential in the soil. Beyond weed control, sorghum sudangrass excels in improving soil structure and health. Its deep and extensive root system breaks up compacted soil layers, enhancing soil porosity and aeration. This root action not only facilitates better water infiltration and storage but also promotes the activity of beneficial soil organisms by increasing organic matter and available nutrients in the soil profile. Just remember the allelopathic effect (preventing weeds or the crop growing) last for 10-14 days after soil incorporation!

The benefits of sudangrass extend to its role in adding organic matter to the soil when it is mowed and incorporated as green manure. This process means making sure the plant is in a 30-40:1 Carbon to Nitrogen ratio. The decomposition of sudangrass residue releases significant amounts of nutrients, especially nitrogen, which are then available for subsequent crops, thereby improving soil fertility. Additionally, sudangrass has been noted for its biofumigant properties, particularly when specific varieties are used. The breakdown of its tissues can release compounds that suppress soil-borne pathogens and nematodes, further promoting a healthy soil environment conducive to high-yielding crops. However, it’s important to manage sudangrass properly, as allowing it to reach maturity (beyond the 40:1 carbon to nitrogen ratio) can result in a tough, woody residue that is slower to decompose and might interfere with planting subsequent crops.

Sunn hemp (picture above) is increasingly recognized for its substantial benefits as a cover crop, particularly in warm climates where it thrives. One of the key advantages of incorporating sunn hemp into crop rotations is its ability to rapidly accumulate biomass, which, when turned into the soil, significantly enhances soil organic matter. This increase in organic matter improves soil structure, water retention, and nutrient availability, leading to a more fertile and resilient soil ecosystem. Moreover, sunn hemp is an excellent nitrogen fixer, capturing atmospheric nitrogen and converting it into a form that subsequent crops can easily absorb. This natural fertilization process reduces the need for synthetic nitrogen inputs, lowering production costs and minimizing environmental impact.

However, while sunn hemp offers numerous benefits, there are also challenges associated with its cultivation. One potential issue is its allelopathic properties, which can inhibit the germination and growth of subsequent crops if not managed properly. This is due to compounds released by sunn hemp into the soil that can affect sensitive plants, or it can work to keep weeds out! Additionally, sunn hemp may pose a risk of becoming invasive if not carefully controlled. This risk underscores the importance of implementing appropriate management practices, such as timely mowing or incorporation into the soil before seed set, to prevent unwanted spread. Despite these challenges, the benefits of sunn hemp, particularly in terms of soil health enhancement and its role in sustainable agriculture practices, often outweigh the potential drawbacks, making it a valuable tool in the arsenal of organic farmers aiming for weed control and soil health benefits.

Good video about Sunn Hemp from Missouri research!

Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata) (picture above) serves as an excellent cover crop in a variety of agricultural systems, providing multiple benefits for soil health and weed management. Its ability to thrive in poor soil conditions, coupled with a relatively low requirement for water, makes cowpea a robust choice for enhancing soil fertility and structure, especially in regions prone to drought. As a leguminous plant, cowpea enriches the soil with nitrogen through symbiotic nitrogen fixation, a process where bacteria in cowpea roots convert atmospheric nitrogen into a form that plants can use. This natural fertilization boosts the nutrient content of the soil, reducing the need for synthetic fertilizers and thereby lowering agricultural input costs.

In terms of weed control, cowpea’s rapid growth and dense foliage provide an effective cover that suppresses weed emergence by significantly reducing light penetration to the soil surface, thus minimizing the growth opportunities for unwanted plants. The shading effect also helps in retaining soil moisture, further supporting the growth of the cowpea while inhibiting weed development (this effect is not nearly as effective because it is a shorter plant). Additionally, when cowpea is incorporated into the soil as green manure after its growth cycle, the organic matter added to the soil improves soil structure, enhances water retention, and stimulates the activity of beneficial microorganisms. However, it’s important to manage cowpea cover crops effectively to prevent them from becoming a weed themselves, as their vigorous growth can sometimes lead to challenges in controlling their spread if not timely mowed or incorporated into the soil. Overall, cowpea stands out as a versatile and beneficial cover crop, contributing to sustainable agricultural practices by improving soil health, enhancing nutrient availability, and providing effective weed suppression.

Winter cover is more difficult because we typically start to get land ready about the time our cover crops start to grow in February/March.  Winter cover is almost always a small grain and most of the time we use a “combine run” wheat or oat since they are cheaper with a planting of turnips or daikon radish or both.  

Cereal rye (not ryegrass), scientifically known as Secale cereale (pictured above), serves as an exceptional cover crop for a multitude of reasons, pivotal for enhancing agricultural sustainability and soil health. One of its foremost benefits is its robust root system, which significantly improves soil structure and enhances water infiltration. This characteristic is particularly valuable in preventing soil erosion and runoff, thus protecting water quality in the surrounding environment. Additionally, cereal rye’s ability to uptake residual nitrogen from the soil makes it an excellent tool for nutrient management, reducing the risk of nitrogen leaching into water bodies and thereby mitigating the environmental impact of nitrogen fertilizers.

Moreover, cereal rye acts as a natural weed suppressant due to its quick germination and fast growth, outcompeting weeds for light, nutrients, and space. The crop’s residue also provides a mulch that further suppresses weed growth and retains soil moisture, which is particularly beneficial in dryland farming systems. Furthermore, by providing a habitat for beneficial insects and microorganisms, cereal rye enhances biodiversity and contributes to the overall health of the agroecosystem.

This picture is from Carl Pepper near O’Donnell on the South Plains. It was planted last September into cotton plants. Seeding rate is 4.5 lbs. of Rye and 4.5 lbs. of Barley with 1 lb. of purple top turnips burned in the freeze. Holds the soil, uses very little if any moisture and is cheap to establish.

Short video of Roller Crimping a rye cover crop at pollination

Using mustards as a cover crop is a practice rich in benefits for sustainable and organic agriculture. Mustards contribute significantly to soil health and pest management strategies without reliance on chemical inputs. They are known for their rapid growth, which quickly covers bare soil, reducing erosion and suppressing weed growth through competition. The deep rooting of mustards helps break up compacted soil layers, enhancing water infiltration and aeration for future crops. Perhaps most notably, mustards possess biofumigant properties; when incorporated into the soil, they release natural compounds that suppress a variety of soil-borne pathogens and pests (click here for a great project with mustard seed meal). This dual action of physical soil improvement and chemical pest suppression makes mustards an invaluable tool in the organic farmer’s toolkit, promoting a healthier, more productive soil ecosystem and paving the way for successful crop rotations.

“Caliente Rojo” mustard is a variety specifically bred for its biofumigation properties, which can play a significant role in organic agriculture, particularly in disease management and soil health improvement.

  • Biofumigation Properties: “Caliente Rojo” mustard, when incorporated into the soil, releases isothiocyanates (ITCs), which are naturally occurring compounds found in Brassica plants. These compounds have been shown to suppress a wide range of soil-borne pathogens, including fungi, bacteria, nematodes, and some weed species.
  • Soil Health Improvement: Beyond disease suppression, “Caliente Rojo” mustard contributes to soil health by adding organic matter, improving soil structure, and enhancing microbial activity. This leads to better water infiltration, aeration, and nutrient cycling in the soil.
  • Growth Habit: It has a fast growth rate, which quickly provides ground cover, reducing soil erosion and weed growth. Its deep rooting system can also help in breaking up compacted layers of soil, improving root penetration for subsequent crops.
  • Sowing: It is typically sown in the fall or early spring when the soil can be worked. The planting rate and spacing should be adjusted based on the specific goals (biofumigation, erosion control, etc.). Typical planting rate is 8 lbs./ac. but can be lower.
  • Incorporation: For biofumigation, the mustard should be mowed or chopped and immediately incorporated into the soil while it is still fresh. This action releases the biofumigant compounds.
  • Irrigation: After incorporation, irrigating the area can help in releasing the biofumigant compounds more effectively as they hydrolyze in the presence of water.

Common vetch (Vicia sativa) and hairy vetch (Vicia villosa) are leguminous cover crops celebrated for their multifaceted benefits in sustainable agriculture. These species excel in nitrogen fixation, a process where atmospheric nitrogen is converted into a form that plants can use, enriching the soil and reducing the need for synthetic fertilizers. This attribute makes them particularly valuable in crop rotations, especially preceding nutrient-demanding crops. Hairy vetch, with its robust growth and cold tolerance, is particularly noted for producing a significant amount of biomass, which can improve soil structure and organic matter content.

Both common and hairy vetch exhibit vigorous root systems that enhance soil health by increasing porosity and water infiltration, thereby reducing erosion and improving drought resilience. Their dense foliage serves as an excellent weed suppressant by outcompeting weed species for sunlight and nutrients, which can lead to reduced herbicide reliance. Upon termination, the biomass of these vetch species acts as a natural mulch, conserving soil moisture and further suppressing weed growth. Additionally, the flowers of vetch attract beneficial insects, including pollinators and predatory insects, which contribute to the biodiversity and resilience of agroecosystems.

Hairy vetch, in particular, stands out for its ability to thrive in a wide range of soil conditions and its notable winter hardiness, making it an excellent choice for cover cropping in cooler climates where other legumes might fail to establish or survive. Hairy vetch will produce more residue than common vetch 1/3 to 1/2 more. Common vetch does tend to reseed and establish easier in a pasture system compared to hairy vetch. When used in a no-till farming system, the decomposing vetch residue can release nitrogen slowly over time, closely matching the nutrient uptake patterns of subsequent crops. This synchrony minimizes nitrogen leaching and maximizes nutrient use efficiency, showcasing the role of vetch not only in enhancing soil fertility but also in promoting more sustainable and environmentally friendly farming practices.

  • Advantages: Wheat is widely adaptable, with a deep root system that improves soil structure and enhances water infiltration. It’s excellent for erosion control and can be a good scavenger of residual soil nitrogen, reducing nitrate leaching. Wheat also serves as a decent biomass producer in cooler climates.
  • Best For: Erosion control, nitrogen scavenging, and when a crop that can survive a wide range of conditions is needed.
  • Advantages: Oats are fast-growing and establish quickly, providing rapid ground cover to outcompete weeds and reduce erosion. They produce significant biomass, which can improve soil organic matter. Oats also die off in freezing temperatures, which makes them easy to manage in the spring.
  • Best For: Quick cover to outcompete weeds, adding organic matter to the soil, and as a winter-kill cover crop in regions with cold winters.
  • Advantages: Barley establishes quickly and can provide a good ground cover and weed suppression. It’s more drought-tolerant than oats and can be used in areas with lower water availability. Barley also contributes to soil health by adding biomass and improving soil structure.
  • Best For: Fast establishment, drought-prone areas, and effective weed suppression.
  • Advantages: Triticale, a wheat and rye hybrid, combines the best traits of both parents. It offers a robust root system, excellent biomass production, and good tolerance to both poor soil conditions and colder temperatures. Triticale is also notable for its nutrient scavenging ability and can be used to improve soil fertility.
  • Best For: Biomass production, nutrient scavenging, and versatility in both cold and marginal soil conditions.

Daikon radish, often referred to as tillage radish, has gained popularity as a cover crop for its unique ability to improve soil structure and health through natural biotillage. Characterized by its rapid growth and large, penetrating taproot, tillage radish drills through compacted soil layers, creating channels that enhance air and water infiltration. This deep penetration also helps to break up hardpans, reducing the need for mechanical soil tillage, hence the name “tillage radish.”

One of the standout benefits of tillage radish is its capacity to capture excess nutrients from the soil profile. The deep roots absorb nitrogen and other nutrients, which are then stored in the plant’s tissue. When the radishes decompose in the spring, these nutrients are released back into the soil, becoming available for the next crop. This nutrient recycling can improve crop yields while reducing the risk of nutrient runoff into waterways, contributing to more sustainable farming practices.

Tillage radish also contributes to weed suppression. The rapid, dense canopy formation shades out weeds, reducing their ability to establish. This effect can carry over into the spring, providing a cleaner start for the next crop. Additionally, the decaying radish residue leaves behind significant organic matter, contributing to soil organic matter content and overall soil health. This organic matter feeds soil microorganisms, which play a critical role in maintaining soil fertility.

Moreover, the winter die-off of tillage radish eliminates the need for chemical or mechanical termination, simplifying spring field operations. This characteristic makes it an attractive option for farmers looking to reduce labor and input costs associated with cover crop management. The holes left by the decomposing radishes can also improve soil aeration and provide pathways for the roots of subsequent crops, potentially enhancing root development and access to deep soil nutrients.

Purple top turnip is a cover crop that has been used for years in Texas. The seed is relatively cheap, serves as winter grazing if needed, grows fast and adds lots of organic matter. It is known for its rapid growth and adaptability to a wide range of soil types, this cover crop is an excellent choice for farmers looking to enhance soil structure, suppress weeds, and improve nutrient cycling within their farming systems. The large, leafy greens of the purple top turnip create a dense canopy that can quickly cover the ground, effectively suppressing weed growth by outcompeting weeds for sunlight and nutrients.